12 farms, butchers, and fisheries that ship real meat. Ranked.

#2Grass Roots Farmers' Cooperative

4.8

Farmer-owned cooperative — the strictest welfare standard in the directory

From $179 / boxRead review →

#3Crowd Cow

4.7

Marketplace — buy direct from named farms, by the cut

Per-cut, from $40Read review →

#4Porter Road

4.7

Whole-animal butchery — pasture-raised, dry-aged in-house

From $149 / boxRead review →

Pasture-raised, grass-finished

Sources tracked

Editor's #1 pick

Wild Pastures

Easiest start

ButcherBox

Re-verified

Weekly

The directory · Updated weekly

Where to buy meat that didn't come from a feedlot

Twelve farms, butchers, and fisheries — ranked by sourcing transparency, certification depth, catalog breadth, and effective per-pound price.

Full directory

Top meat-delivery brands, ranked by editor score, reader trust, and recency.
Rank	Provider	Best for	Type	Editor
#1	Wild Pastures Grass-fed beef · Pasture-raised pork · Read review	Editor pick 1	regenerative brand	4.9 / 5	Visit source
#2	Grass Roots Farmers' Cooperative Grass-fed beef · Pasture-raised pork · Read review	Farmer owned	regenerative brand	4.8 / 5	Visit source
#3	Crowd Cow Grass-fed beef · Pasture-raised pork · Read review	Transparency	marketplace	4.7 / 5	Visit source
#4	Porter Road Grass-fed beef · Pasture-raised pork · Read review	Home cooks	specialty butcher	4.7 / 5	Visit source
#5	D'Artagnan Game meat · Heritage poultry · Read review	Game meat	game heritage	4.7 / 5	Visit source
#6	Vital Choice Wild-caught seafood · Read review	Wild salmon	wild seafood	4.7 / 5	Visit source
#7	ButcherBox Grass-fed beef · Pasture-raised pork · Read review	Editor pick 2	subscription box	4.7 / 5	Visit source
#8	US Wellness Meats Grass-fed beef · Pasture-raised pork · Read review	Organ meats	regenerative brand	4.6 / 5	Visit source
#9	Holy Grail Steak Co American Wagyu · Grass-fed beef · Read review	A5 wagyu	premium steakhouse	4.6 / 5	Visit source
#10	Snake River Farms American Wagyu · Grass-fed beef · Read review	Wagyu	premium steakhouse	4.6 / 5	Visit source
#11	Force of Nature Meats Grass-fed beef · Bison · Read review	Ancestral	regenerative brand	4.5 / 5	Visit source
#12	Good Chop Grass-fed beef · Pasture-raised pork · Read review	Customization	subscription box	4.3 / 5	Visit source

Top 5 sources, in depth

The detail under each top pick — what the source actually is, who it fits, what it costs, who raised the animals.

See all 12 →

★ Editor's Pick Sample available

Wild Pastures

Regenerative-ag brand · Grass-fed beef · Pasture-raised pork

4.9

100% pasture-raised, regenerative-ag meat box — beef, pork, chicken, and lamb sourced from a small network of small American family farms.

✓ 100% pasture-raised across all proteins (no feedlot finish)
✓ Small US family farm network — actual transparency
✓ Customizable boxes + flexible cadence

− Subscription required — no one-time purchase
− Higher per-pound price than supermarket conventional
− Frozen-only delivery (standard for the category)

Verified May 7, 2026

Visit sourceAffiliate linkRead review →

★ Editor's Pick Sample available

Grass Roots Farmers' Cooperative

Regenerative-ag brand · Grass-fed beef · Pasture-raised pork

4.8

Member-owned farmer cooperative — every cut traces back to a farmer-owner, with the highest welfare and pasture standards in the directory.

✓ Farmer-owned cooperative — economic alignment with producers
✓ Strict, audited pasture + welfare standards
✓ 15% commission new / 10% returning (highest in directory)

− Smaller catalog than ButcherBox or Crowd Cow
− Premium price reflects co-op pricing
− Direct affiliate (no public network) — application required

Verified May 7, 2026

Visit sourceAffiliate linkRead review →

★ Editor's Pick Sample available

Crowd Cow

Multi-farm marketplace · Grass-fed beef · Pasture-raised pork

4.7

Multi-farm marketplace — buy direct from named small farms across the US, plus curated subscriptions and one-off boxes. Strongest sourcing transparency of any major brand.

✓ Farm-level sourcing transparency (rare in the category)
✓ Both one-time and subscription purchase models
✓ Rare-item depth (A5 Wagyu, heritage breeds, specialty seafood)

− Per-pound pricing is premium
− Inventory rotation means your favorite farm may be sold out
− Shipping cost on smaller orders adds up

Verified May 7, 2026

Visit sourceAffiliate linkRead review →

★ Editor's Pick Sample available

Porter Road

Whole-animal butcher · Grass-fed beef · Pasture-raised pork

4.7

Pasture-raised, dry-aged whole-animal butchery — Nashville-based butchers shipping the cuts butcher shops keep for their best customers.

✓ Whole-animal butchery — best access to underrated cuts
✓ In-house dry-aging on beef
✓ Pasture-raised across all proteins

− Subscription model less flexible than ButcherBox
− Smaller catalog than marketplace players
− Dry-aged premium isn't for everyone

Verified May 7, 2026

Visit sourceAffiliate linkRead review →

★ Editor's Pick Sample available

D'Artagnan

Game + heritage poultry · Game meat · Heritage poultry

4.7

The original American game and heritage-poultry source — duck, venison, wild boar, foie gras, and charcuterie since 1985.

✓ Best US source for game (venison, wild boar, duck)
✓ Heritage-breed turkey for holidays
✓ Strong charcuterie + cured meat catalog

− Premium pricing across the board
− Specialty catalog — not for everyday cooking
− Some items seasonal-only

Verified May 7, 2026

Visit sourceAffiliate linkRead review →

Browse by what you cook

Top sources by category

The right source depends on what you actually cook. Pick the category and we'll surface the farms, butchers, or fisheries that ship it best.

Grass-fed beef

Heritage breeds + welfare-audited

Pasture-raised pork

Wild Alaskan, MSC-certified

Wild-caught seafood

USDA Organic, pasture-raised

Organic chicken

Multi-protein curated boxes

Subscription boxes

American Wagyu

Premium-grade marbling

Naturally grass-fed, lean

Bison

Cured meats, prosciutto, salami

Charcuterie

Bone broth

Slow-simmered grass-fed

Game meat

Venison, wild boar, elk

Heritage turkey, duck, goose

Heritage poultry

Beef + heart + liver patties

Ancestral blends

Wild Pastures vs. ButcherBox

Head-to-head

Pick between two sources

The choices most readers actually face — pasture-purist vs the volume leader, marketplace vs whole-animal butcher, curated box vs pick-your-cuts. Real per-pound math, real sourcing data.

Wild Pastures vs ButcherBox in 2026 — pasture-raised regenerative-ag subscription vs the largest source. Sourcing depth, customization, welcome offers, per-pound math.

Crowd Cow vs. Porter Road

Crowd Cow vs Porter Road in 2026 — multi-farm marketplace vs whole-animal butchery. Sourcing model, cut depth, dry-aging, per-pound pricing.

ButcherBox vs Good Chop in 2026 — curated multi-protein box vs HelloFresh's flexible pick-your-cuts subscription. Sourcing, customization, welcome offers, per-pound math.

ButcherBox vs. Good Chop

Wild Pastures vs. Crowd Cow

Wild Pastures vs Crowd Cow in 2026 — curated pasture-raised subscription vs multi-farm marketplace. Sourcing model, customization, per-pound math, decision framework.

Snake River Farms vs. Holy Grail Steak

Snake River Farms vs Holy Grail Steak in 2026 — American Wagyu pioneer vs widest premium-steak catalog. Marbling grades, A5 Japanese, gifting comparison.

Vital Choice vs. Wild Alaskan Company

Vital Choice vs Wild Alaskan Company in 2026 — premium seafood specialist vs accessible wild-Alaskan-only subscription. Sourcing, MSC certification, per-pound pricing.